Head-to-head

Brilliant Earth vs James Allen

Two fashion & beauty affiliate programs, compared side by side on what a referral is worth, how each pays, the cookie window, and how to get approved. Every figure is verified to its source.

Brilliant Earth has the higher modelled value per referral

Brilliant Earth models at ~$100 per paid referral versus ~$70 for James Allen (both pay per conversion), reasoned from each program's published terms. Value per referral is a modelled comparison aid, not a guarantee: what you actually earn depends on your audience, traffic and conversion.

Side-by-side comparison of Brilliant Earth vs James Allen: value per referral, payout shape, commission, cookie window, network, requirements and verification.
Program
Value / referral
$100
modelled
$70
modelled
Payout shape
One-time

CPS: percentage commission on each qualifying online jewelry sale.

One-time

3.5% commission on each referred sale through Blue Nile's affiliate program, which James Allen's affiliate page now leads to.

Commission

5% on loose diamonds, engagement rings and wedding bands; 7% on fine jewelry ($500 commission cap per order)

Verified

3.5% per sale

Verified
Cookie window30 daysNot posted
NetworkImpactIn-house (Blue Nile)
Requirements to join

Free to join via the Impact platform; apply through the Brilliant Earth affiliate page and get approved; content site or social audience required.

Apply with the form on Blue Nile's affiliates page; jewelry, lifestyle or wedding content fits.

VerifiedOct 25, 2026 · 2 sourcesOct 21, 2026 · 2 sources
Apply

Value per referral is a modelled estimate reasoned from each program's published terms, not a guaranteed payout. A recurring cut and a one-time bounty are different kinds of money, so the payout shape is shown for each. How we verify & model value.

More Fashion & beauty comparisons

Frequently asked

Is Brilliant Earth or James Allen the better affiliate program?
On modelled value per referral, Brilliant Earth leads (~$100 vs ~$70 for James Allen), both pay per conversion. It is a comparison aid, not guaranteed earnings.
How much does the Brilliant Earth affiliate program pay compared to James Allen?
Brilliant Earth pays 5% on loose diamonds, engagement rings and wedding bands; 7% on fine jewelry ($500 commission cap per order). It has a 30-day cookie and is modelled at ~$100 per paid referral. James Allen pays 3.5% per sale. It has no published cookie window and is modelled at ~$70 per paid referral. Both figures are modelled comparison aids reasoned from published terms, not guaranteed earnings.
Which has the longer cookie window, Brilliant Earth or James Allen?
Brilliant Earth has a 30-day cookie window, while James Allen does not publish a fixed cookie window (it is set per advertiser inside its network).

Terms for both programs verified against their own sources. How we verify